Compressor Ice Cream Maker Ultimate Buying Guide

Are you looking for a Compressor Ice Cream Machine? Can you imagine whipping up a batch of ice cream just in time for dinner? (Or any other time if you are an ice cream lover like me!) Producing your own ice cream is easy when you have a compressor ice cream maker. There are quite a few ice cream machines on the market and when you are choosing you want to buy the right one. But how do you know which one is right for you? Before you go buying any compressor ice cream maker lets take a look at what our research has uncovered about the “best” Compressor Ice Cream Machine on the market.

Whynter 2.1 Quart Upright Ice Cream Maker with Stainless Steel Bowl
In the picture: Whynter 2.1 Quart
Upright Ice Cream Maker
get more info:
Whynter 2.1 Quart Upright Ice Cream Maker

3 Best Compressor Ice Cream Makers:

  1. Whynter 2.1 Quart Upright Ice Cream Maker
  2. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker
  3. Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker

Amazon have their own list of best Compressor Ice Cream Machines below – many are on sale.

If you’re curious (or in a hurry):

This specific Compressor Ice Cream Machine is the most popular with our readers.

It can make 2 quarts of ice cream. It has a removable stainless steel bowl and the churner blade is BPA free.

The upright design of this compressor ice cream maker makes it space efficient so it will not take up too much room on your countertop. Press pause to check the consistency of your ice cream or to add those special extras!

You can also use it to make gelato, sorbet and frozen yogurt!  And you will also find that it is also one of the best priced  compressor ice cream makers you’ll find online.

It has a load of 5-Star reviews. If you can get it for under $330, grab it. That’s one heck of a deal on a really great compressor ice cream maker! (check current price & read reviews here).

Which Compressor Ice Cream Machine Is The Best?

When it comes to the compressor ice cream makers with the best ratings, these are the 6 best  to choose from. All are great compressor ice cream makers and for a reasonable price. (compare these 6 compressor ice cream makers here)

Compressor Ice Cream Machine – Best Choices:

  1. Whynter 2.1 Quart Upright Ice Cream Maker – info page
  2. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker – info page
  3. Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker – info page
  4. Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker – info page
  5. Gourmia GSI200 Automatic Ice Cream Maker Stainless Steel 1.6 Qt – info page
  6. Knox Gear Automatic Ice Cream Maker – info page

What do Consumer Reports reviews say about Compressor Ice Cream Makers? After their own in-depth testing and independent review process, Consumer Reports also chose this same Ice Cream Maker as their winner and best all-around Compressor Ice Cream Machine.

We’ll look into this more below.

ANY of the 6 Compressor Ice Cream Machines in the list above are great units that you should be very happy with.


Compare ONLY the 6 Compressor Ice Cream Makers above on One Page Here

buying tip: watch that page above for deals on the Gourmia GSI200 Automatic Ice Cream Maker Stainless Steel 1.6 Qt (#5 on the list) – if it’s under $155, it’s a GREAT deal.

Compressor Ice Cream Machine Buying Guide

So let’s find a compressor ice cream machine that YOU will love.

That’s what this Compressor Ice Cream Machine Buying Guide is for – to help you figure out what you need from your Ice Cream Maker, compare inexpensive models and high-end Compressor Ice Cream Maker brands, see current sale prices on the Ice Cream Makers with the best rating to get the best deal, etc… all with the end goal of helping YOU find the perfect ice cream maker for YOUR needs.

This Buying Guide will help you navigate ALL the “best” Compressor Ice Cream Machines 2017 has to offer – and help you find the right one for YOU.

Compressor Ice Cream Maker VS Churning Ice Cream Maker

Admittedly, compressor ice cream makers are more expensive than the “frozen bowl” type of ice cream maker. And they are usually larger than a churning ice cream machine. They have a freezing mechanism built in, in the form of a coolant, so you do not need to freeze the bowl before you start. You just pour in your ingredients, switch it on and wait for your ice cream to appear. Because these machines can be used immediately with no preparation, you can make as many batches of ice cream as you want without any delay.

Churning ice cream makers use a bowl that is first frozen in a freezer usually overnight. It is the frozen bowl that freezes your ingredients into ice cream while a paddle “churns” the ice cream keeping it smooth, aerated and ice free.

Churning ice cream makers are cheaper than compressor ice cream makers, but you have to remember to freeze your bowl in advance.

Advantages of making ice cream with a Compressor Ice Cream Maker

Check the list of ingredients on any container of ice cream you buy from the super market and you will find that you do not recognize half the items in a list of ingredients! Ingredients could be vegetable emulsifier, vegetable gum, citric acid, thickeners and artificial flavorings. Some of these ingredients are added to preserve the ice cream for a longer period of time, but if you are eating your ice cream within a few days why do you want all these unnatural things in it? Purchase an ice cream maker and it will be up to you which ingredients go into your ice cream!

If you are trying to lose weight, are lactose intolerant, paleo or vegan or are trying to cut down on sugar – no more having to pay through the nose for expensive, specialty ice creams or low fat ice creams with no taste and weird ingredients! Now you can decide which kind of milk you want to use and how much fat and sugar goes into your ice cream.

With your own ice cream maker you can experiment and put in any kind of addition – fruits, nuts, sprinkles, chocolate chips, candy  – and make ice cream any flavor you want to – the only limit is your imagination! (Even savory ice cream if you feel like pushing the boundaries!!)

How to choose a Compressor Ice Cream Maker?

Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker, 2.1-Quart
In the picture: Whynter ICM-200LS
Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker
get more info:
Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker

When it comes to compressor ice cream makers, they all work in the same way, they all use the same coolant and they all have the same motors that spin at around 25 RPMs.

So, how do you choose a compressor ice cream maker?

One of the major decisions will be the size of the ice cream maker – just how much ice cream can you make in one batch?

There are two 2.1 quart (2 liter) models and they are both from Whynter – the Whynter ICM-200LS and the Whynter 2.1 quart Upright ICM201SB (our number 1 pick).

The next largest compressor ice cream maker is the Gourmia GSI200 Automatic Ice Cream Maker which can produce 1.6 quarts (1.5 liters) of ice cream.

Most other compressor ice cream machines are capable of producing 1.5 quarts (1.4 liters) quarts including the Cuisinart ICE-100, and the Knox Gear Automatic.

The Lello 4080 Musso is a little different, it is made in Italy and the outside, bowl and paddle are all made of stainless steel. The bowl is not removable which is similar to a commercial machine and allows the compressor to work in a more efficient manner. Reviewers say clean up is easy with a sponge or paper towel.

How to make ice cream using a Compressor Ice Cream Maker

Measure out your ingredients. Measure out the ingredients required for the ice cream recipe you are using. Make sure that the volume of the ingredients does not exceed the volume that your ice cream maker is capable of holding otherwise you will have ice cream overflowing out of the machine.

Start your ice cream maker. Start your compressor ice cream maker before you add your ice cream mix, otherwise it will start to freeze around the edges before your paddle starts moving.

Add any extras. Approximately five minutes before your ice cream is ready, add any extras such as nuts, chocolate chips, sprinkles or candy.

Eat your yummy ice cream! Your ice cream machine will usually beep to alert you that your ice cream is ready (usually around 45 minutes). You can either eat your ice cream now (if you like your ice cream soft serve) or transfer your ice cream to an airtight container and place it in the freezer for a few hours for a harder texture. Make sure you choose an insulated container as it will be able to keep the ice cream as cold and stable as possible. They also prevent freezer burn and ice crystals from forming.

What can you make using a Compressor Ice Cream Maker?

The great thing about having your own ice cream maker is that you can cater for those who cannot eat “mainstream” ice cream. That is those who are lactose intolerant or vegan using nut, soy, goats or coconut milk. Those who are following a paleo or low carb diet, and those who are trying to remove sugar from their diet by using dates, honey, maple syrup, agave, stevia or Erythritol instead.

Apart from ice cream, you can also make, sorbets, gelatos, frozen yogurt and slushies! And ice cream does not just have to be vanilla – how about chocolate, coffee, pecan, strawberry, mint, choc chip, mango, raspberry, blue berry, banana, salted caramel, peanut butter…. and have you tried savory ice cream yet?

✅ Compressor Ice Cream Maker WINNER

Which Compressor Ice Cream Maker is the BEST? If we had to pick just ONE Compressor Ice Cream Machine we agree with Amazon on the results below:
Breville BC1600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker Amazons choice
Amazon chooses the Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker as their ‘Amazon’s Choice‘ 2017 Winner. It has a 1 liter (1 1/2 quart) capacity and can make sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream.

It has 12 hardness settings so you can program it to produce your frozen dessert in the exact consistency that you require. The pre-cool setting takes your ingredients down to the correct temperature before you start your churning.

When your ice cream is ready you can choose to be alerted by either a beep or one of three “ice cream van” tunes!

Looking at all the reviews for this ice cream maker, based on price, user experiences & feedback, value, quality, size, and quality of the frozen desserts it produces – this is the best compressor ice cream machine you can buy that fits all budgets and ice cream making needs.

What IS GREAT about this Compressor ice cream machine that Amazon and our readers picked as their winner, is that it allows you to create ice cream without any of the additives or flavorings that come in the ice cream you buy. And you can make your own low fat, low carb, lactose free or vegan ice cream without the high price that these “specialty” ice creams come with at the super market!

This Compressor Ice Cream Machine is rated = 4.2/5

You can see Amazon’s Choice Winner here: Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker